First Presbyterian Church 1923
First Presbyterian Church, circa 1923

from “A Brief Account of the Heritage and Creation of Nassau Presbyterian Church”

Early Days

In colonial Princeton, Presbyterians had to travel to either Lawrenceville or Kingston to worship. After the College of New Jersey (now Princeton University) moved to Princeton in 1756, regular worship services were held in the Prayer Room of the newly-constructed Nassau Hall. A few years later an agreement was reached with the college for the construction of a church building. The First Presbyterian Church of Princeton was founded in 1766 and met on the site where worship continues today. John Witherspoon, President of the College, began 25 years of serving also as pastor of First Church in 1768.

The church building was occupied by both British and American soldiers during the Revolution. The pews and galleries were stripped for firewood and burned in a makeshift fireplace inside the sanctuary. After the war, the devastated building was restored and services resumed in 1784. The original building burned to the ground in 1813 when a sexton accidentally stored live coals in a closet. It was rebuilt in eight months, but that building was destroyed by fire in 1835 when a skyrocket fired in celebration of Independence Day landed on the roof.

Rebuilding and Separation

The original portion of the present building was designed and built by Charles Steadman and dedicated in 1836. During construction, most of the congregation met in the new Princeton Theological Seminary Chapel. The history, however, is not all to be celebrated. In the time of sanctuary construction, ninety African-American members worshiped separately. After the church was built, there continued a separation that led to the formation of Witherspoon Street Presbyterian Church in 1846. In writing about this part of our past, Lefferts Loetscher wrote “it is earnestly hoped that time and the grace of God will heal such wounds in our church, in our town, and in our nation.”

The Second Presbyterian Church was founded in 1847 by eleven members of First Church. Its formation was in response to the need for increased church accommodations as well as the desire for more informal worship. The initial discussions about forming a second church started in 1832. The chartering of Second Church came years later after some lively disagreements about pastoral leadership and worship style. The first sanctuary is now an office building at 190 Nassau Street. Second Church soon outgrew the space in that building and constructed a new sanctuary at the corner of Nassau and Chambers that was dedicated in 1868.

The three Presbyterian Churches maintained a cordial and cooperative relationship over the years. However, efforts at merger between First and Second in 1896, 1905, and 1963-64 were not successful. Second Church rededicated its renovated sanctuary in 1965 and was renamed St. Andrew’s Presbyterian Church, “recalling the effective discipleship of St. Andrew… whose example of outreach and concern it behooves us all to follow.”

Nassau Presbyterian Church

In 1972, both First and St. Andrew’s were without senior ministers. Each had begun the search process. In early 1973, the Session of First proposed the constitution of a new church, dissolving the existing charters. Witherspoon Street Church declined an invitation to participate in the merger discussions. A Joint Committee on Merger was formed and in less than 100 days a new church was established by an overwhelming vote of the members at First and St. Andrew’s. The initial congregation had 2,335 members with 1,759 and 576 coming from First and St. Andrew’s, respectively.

On June 24, 1973, a moving Service of Constitution was held in Alexander Hall to formalize the beginning of the Nassau Presbyterian Church. The Rev. Dr. Wallace M. Alston, Jr., was called to be the first pastor in March 1974 and soon after the Rev. Cynthia Jarvis was called as Associate Pastor.

For several years, worship and education activities were held in both buildings. The Chambers Street building was sold to the Nassau Christian Center in 1978. The proceeds were used to establish the St. Andrew’s Mission Fund, dedicated to provide income for “basic human needs.” In 1987-88, there was a renovation of the entire Palmer Square building and the addition of the office wing.

Dr. Alston left Nassau in 1996 to become Director of the Center of Theological Inquiry in Princeton. The Rev. Dr. Clarence Ammons served as interim pastor for four years until the Rev. Dr. David A. Davis was called in May, 2000. The Rev. Lauren J. McFeaters was called in June 2001 as Associate Pastor.

By God’s grace we step into the future of Nassau Presbyterian Church. We are mindful of a diverse past that now includes four distinct congregations. We strive to honestly wrestle with and celebrate our history while confidently moving forward into God’s future.

Growing out of the important and ongoing conversations with our partners at the Witherspoon Street Presbyterian Church and our ongoing commitment to the hard work of racial reconciliation, the Session would like to update the congregation on conversation and action. A request to remove the small name plates from pews in the sanctuary and outside of Niles Chapel was referred to the Mission and Outreach Committee. The committee’s response and the following action of Session from March 16, 2023, can be downloaded by using the button below.